About Make My Cake

Baking the sweetest memories! Visit us online at makemycake.com.
Make My Cake is a full-service retail and wholesale bakery specializing in scrumptious baked goods that boast both Southern flavor and Harlem inspiration. For the past 15 years, Make My Cake has offered their clientele heavenly desserts such as the homestyle butter cake, the New York Times’ pick, Red Velvet Cake, Food Network favorite, German Chocolate Cake, and local best-seller, Sweet Potato Cheesecake.

2380 Adam Clayton Powell Blvd.
New York, NY 10030

121A St. Nicholas Avenue
New York, NY 10026
Public Transit
Train: 2, 3, B or C.
Bus: M2, M7, M116, M102
Personal Information
Make My Cake is a full service and wholesale bakery specializing in wedding, shower and birthday cakes. Our reputation stands on a Southern family tradition of offering quality ingredients. At Make My Cake, everything is made from scratch. Baked fresh every day at two Harlem locations, our cakes contain no preservatives. We even crack our own eggs! The delicate butter taste and wonderful aroma of our cakes keep loyal customers from around the world coming back for more. You can order any of our desserts (48 hours prior notice) and we will have it personalized, ready and waiting. We also offer sugar free products. Stop by and experience any one of our unforgettable treats. We guarantee it will be one of the ‘sweetest’ experiences in your life.

Don’t live in New York and want to taste the ‘experience’? We ship delicious cupcakes made from a selection of our signature cakes anywhere in the USA!
Culinary Team
The Baylor Family: JoAnn, Kevin, Dedan, Aliyyah and Khalid